Tithely vs Pushpay Pricing (2026)
Compare / Tithely vs Pushpay
Shortlist
Team size
25 seats

Tithely vs Pushpay

Church Management pricing comparison · 2026

Tithely pricing ranges from $0–$119/month, while Pushpay ranges from $99–$600/month. These products use different pricing models ( vs Custom enterprise pricing), so a direct price comparison isn't meaningful — costs depend on usage volume and mix.

Visit
See pricing on each vendor's site
Above-the-fold path — each link opens the vendor's pricing page in a new tab.
Visit Tithely pricing
Free plan limits → Discount programs →
Visit Pushpay pricing
Discount programs →
Compare
2 products · Church Management
Side-by-side · live
Tithely
Tithely pricing starts at $19/mo.
verified 12w ago
$3.0K $5.7K
View pricing →
Pushpay
Pushpay offers three tiers—Core, Advanced, and Complete—all with custom pricing quoted bas
verified 1d ago
$3.0K $5.7K
View pricing →
Estimated license cost
at 25 seats
List price × seats. Click a tier below to lock it.
Custom Church Website
$5.7K/yr
year 1 license · $19/seat
Custom pricing
Custom
all tiers are quote-only
What buyers actually pay
median, annual
Vendr deal-flow data. The real benchmark, not list price.
No Vendr data
—
Not in Vendr's deal flow
Median annual
$3.0K/yr
Vendr · n=1 · limited data
REF · 01

Sources & confidence

Every dollar amount and contract clause below traces back to a sourced fact. We don't manufacture composite scores.

Where this data comes from
Vendr · TrustRadius · Reddit · BBB · official docs
Sources 12 sourced facts
9 hidden-cost · 1 contract · 2 review platforms
Last verified 2mo ago
Confidence Medium confidence
Sources 8 sourced facts
4 hidden-cost · 2 contract · Vendr median · 1 review platform
Last verified 1d ago
Confidence Limited confidence
REF · 02

Plans at a glance

Every tier per product. Lock one to drive the cost row above and reveal a tier-specific outbound CTA.

Tier ladder
Click a tier to lock the cost row to it. Locking surfaces a tier-specific Visit CTA.
REF · 03

Hidden costs

Each cost is severity-ranked, with the dollar range quoted from its source (Vendr, Reddit, TrustRadius, BBB, official docs) — never our estimate.

Beyond the sticker
Severity-ranked, sourced
5 documented
  • Text Giving Subscription
    $19 per month
    1 source
  • Text-to-give Setup Fee
    $25
    1 source
  • Custom Church App Subscription
    $89 per month
    1 source
  • Tithely Messaging Overage
    1.9¢ each
    1 source
  • Premium Support
    $29 per month
    1 source
3 documented
  • Credit Card Transaction Fees
    2.9%
    1 source
  • Annual Contract Lock-In During Migration
    $350/month
    1 source
  • Platform Fees Higher Than Competitors
    10-20% of donation revenue
    2 sources
REF · 04

Contract terms

The fine print, surfaced. Green = buyer-friendly. Each clause backed by a quoted source.

Tithely
Pushpay
Auto-renewal
Yes
Yes
Cancellation
before next scheduled renewal date
Must complete full annual contract term
Commitment
none
1 year
Price escalation
—
—
Can downgrade
—
No
Based on 3 verified sources (Vendr · TrustRadius · BBB)
REF · 05

What users say

Aggregated, with sample sizes. We use whichever review platform has data.

User reviews
TrustRadius · Trustpilot · G2
Trustpilot
4.7out of 5 (1,100)
G2
4.7out of 5 (2,026)
Best for
Churches getting started with digital giving
Watch out
Delayed Payment Processing
TrustRadius
8out of 5 (16)
Best for
Small churches starting digital giving
Watch out
Excessively high fees compared to alternative platforms
Decide
Get a quote from each vendor
Each link opens the vendor's pricing page in a new tab.
Visit Tithely pricing
Free plan limits → Discount programs →
Visit Pushpay pricing
Discount programs →
License cost is computed from publicly listed plans (real math, list price × seats). Median annual cost is from Vendr's deal flow when available — see source badges. Hidden costs and contract terms each cite their own sources. We do not invent composite scores.
Church Management

Tithely

$0–$119
/month
8 plans · Free tier
Full pricing breakdown →
VS
Church Management

Pushpay

$99–$600
/month
3 plans
Full pricing breakdown →
⚖

Different Pricing Models

Direct price comparison isn't meaningful here — Tithely uses pricing while Pushpay uses Custom enterprise pricing pricing. Your actual cost will depend on usage volume, team size, or both. Here's each product in its native unit.

Tithely

$0–$119 / month
See full Tithely pricing →
vs
Custom enterprise pricing

Pushpay

$99–$600 / month
See full Pushpay pricing →

Tithely and Pushpay both operate in the church management category. This page compares their list pricing.

Plan-by-Plan Pricing

Plan Tithely Pushpay
Free Giving Free /user/month Custom
Text Giving $19 /user/month Custom
Custom Church Website $19 /user/month Custom
Worship Team Tools $29 /user/month —
Giving + Church Management $72 /user/month —
Custom Church App $89 /user/month —
All Access $119 /user/month —
Enterprise Custom —

Hidden Costs

Beyond the sticker price — what catches buyers off guard.

Tithely 9 hidden costs

medium
Text Giving Subscription $19 per month
low
Text-to-give Setup Fee $25
medium
Custom Church App Subscription $89 per month
medium
Tithely Messaging Overage 1.9¢ each
medium
Premium Support $29 per month
See all Tithely hidden costs →

Pushpay 3 hidden costs

medium
Credit Card Transaction Fees 2.9%
critical
Annual Contract Lock-In During Migration $350/month
high
Platform Fees Higher Than Competitors 10-20% of donation revenue
See all Pushpay hidden costs →

Contract Terms

Term Tithely Pushpay
Auto-renewal Yes Yes
Cancellation before next scheduled renewal date Must complete full annual contract term
Minimum commitment none 1 year
Can downgrade — No

Continue researching

Tithely

Pushpay

Related Comparisons